top of page

The Pros and Cons of Studded Winter Tires

As winter rolls around, you might ask yourself the question if you should be looking at regular winter tires (often also called snow tires) or studded tires (sometimes known as ice tires). There are many models to choose from, studded, studdable and non-studded, so it can be challenging to decide.

Don't worry; GoWrench Auto is here to help you make sense of it all, and in this blog, we will look at the pros and cons of studded winter tires to hopefully answer all of your questions.

choosing a studded or non-studded winter tire

What Are Studded Winter Tires

Let's start with the immediate question - what are studded tires in the first place?

Studded winter tires take winter preparedness to the next level. Unlike their smooth-riding counterparts, they come equipped with small metal studs embedded in the tread. These studs, often made of tungsten carbide or other durable materials, act as tiny ice picks, enhancing traction on slippery surfaces.

The idea is simple but effective: when the roads turn into ice rinks, studded tires bite into the frosty surface, helping your vehicle stay on the straight and narrow. It's like giving your car winter boots with built-in crampons, ready to conquer the iciest of landscapes.

You have to make the distinction between studdable and studded tires as well. Studdable tires come with holes that allow you to fit studs into them and are installed by a technician, while studded tires already come with the studs installed by the manufacturer.

The studs have a base and a stem, which fits inside the tire, and a metal tip that protrudes from the tread to give you additional tire grip. The base is larger than the tip to ensure the stud remains in place.

The Advantages of Studded Winter Tires

Studded tires come with some significant benefits that can considerably increase winter performance.

Enhanced Ice Traction

The standout feature of studded winter tires is their ability to grip icy roads like a climber on a mountain. The metal studs dig into the ice, providing better traction and reducing the likelihood of slipping and sliding.

Improved Stability on Packed Snow

Studded tires excel in packed snow conditions, offering stability and control. The snow tire studs help prevent the tires from losing grip, ensuring a smoother and safer ride on snow-covered roads.

Shorter Braking Distances

When it comes to stopping on an icy surface, studded tires shine. They can significantly reduce braking distances on icy roads, contributing to overall safety during winter driving.

Confidence in Extreme Winter Conditions

Studded tires instill a sense of confidence when facing extreme winter weather. Whether it's an unexpected ice storm or a deep layer of snow, these tires provide drivers with the assurance that their vehicle can handle the challenge.

extreme driving conditions winter

Effective for Icy Hills and Inclines

Climbing uphill on icy terrain can be a daunting task, but studded tires make it more manageable. The enhanced traction helps prevent your vehicle from slipping backward on inclines, making winter driving less stressful.

Extended Winter Use

Studded tires are specifically designed for winter conditions, and their effectiveness doesn't diminish as much in extremely cold temperatures. This makes them a reliable choice for regions with prolonged and harsh winter seasons.

The Disadvantages of Studded Winter Tires

Road Damage

One of the significant drawbacks of studded tires is their potential to cause damage to road surfaces. The metal studs can wear down asphalt and concrete over time, increasing road maintenance costs. Some regions have even imposed restrictions on studded tires to mitigate this issue.

Noise Levels

Studded tires can be noisy, especially when driving on dry pavement. The metal studs make a distinct clicking or buzzing sound that can be bothersome for the driver and those sharing the road. This noise pollution is a significant downside, particularly in urban areas.

Reduced Traction on Dry Roads

They are not well-suited for dry road conditions. The metal studs that provide excellent traction on ice can reduce tire grip and handling on dry or wet surfaces. Using studded tires when unnecessary can result in a less comfortable driving experience.


Studded tires tend to be more expensive than their non-studded counterparts. Additionally, they may wear out more quickly, requiring more frequent replacements. The initial investment and ongoing costs can be a deterrent for budget-conscious drivers.

Environmental Impact

The manufacturing and disposal of studded tires can have environmental consequences. The production of metal studs and the wear and tear on roads contribute to environmental concerns. Additionally, when winter tire studs break loose, they can become litter on roadways.

Studded or Non-Studded Tires: Which One Is For You?

Choosing between studded and non-studded tires depends on your specific needs, driving conditions, and personal preferences. Let's break down the decision-making process to help you determine which type of tire is the right fit for you:

Studded Tires

If you frequently encounter icy roads or live in an area prone to freezing temperatures, studded tires might be your best bet. They provide traction on icy surfaces, reducing the risk of slipping and sliding.

They are also advantageous when navigating hilly or inclined terrain during winter. The enhanced grip can be crucial for maintaining control on uphill and downhill stretches.

Finally, if you can tolerate the noise generated by studded tires on dry pavement, their winter performance benefits might outweigh this drawback.

Non-Studded Tires

Non-studded tires are more versatile and perform well in various winter conditions. If your winters include a mix of snow, slush, and dry or wet roads, non-studded tires may be a well-rounded choice.

Also, if you're mindful of environmental and road damage considerations, non-studded tires might be a preferable option. They are less likely to cause wear and tear on road surfaces. Non-studded tires also are generally more budget-friendly, both in terms of initial purchase and potential long-term costs. If cost is a significant factor, this may sway your decision.

If you prioritize a quieter driving experience, especially on dry roads, non-studded tires are a more sound-friendly choice than their studded counterparts. And if you live in an area where winters are mild, with occasional snowfall but not severe ice, non-studded tires may provide sufficient traction without the need for metal studs.


Ultimately, the choice between studded and non-studded tires depends on your specific winter driving conditions, preferences, and any legal requirements in your area. Consider the trade-offs and prioritize the most critical factors for a safer and more comfortable winter driving experience.

GoWrench Auto has a wide selection of winter tires and offers a professional winter tire swap service. You don't have space to safely and securely store your tires? No problem; GoWrench Auto's tire storage service has you covered. Our mobile fleet can pick up your tires and keep them in a climate-controlled facility, ensuring they are protected from the elements and ready for use when needed. Say goodbye to cluttered garages and hello to a hassle-free tire storage solution.

If you have ever found yourself stuck somewhere with a car or tire problem, you know that calling and waiting for a tow truck to bring your car to a garage, where you will have to wait even longer, is highly inconvenient. This is why GoWrench Auto brings the service to your location with our mobile auto and tire repair services, whether you need new SUV tires or fix a flat on your car.

With highly-trained mechanics, the right technology, a dedicated customer service team, and the proper equipment, over 500 services can be completed at your workplace, on the job or in your driveway. GoWrench Auto is here to change the way you think about car repairs.

Call us today at (866) 959-1195 to learn how we can help you with your tire change!


bottom of page